Remington 870 And 11-87 Shotguns For Clay Shooting
Choosing between the Remington 870 and 11-87 for clay shooting comes down to how you value simplicity, recoil control, follow-up shots, and maintenance. Both shotguns have earned strong reputations among sporting shooters, but they deliver their strengths in different ways.
The 870 is a pump-action shotgun known for its straightforward design and dependable cycling. The 11-87 is a gas-operated semi-automatic that can offer faster second shots and a softer-feeling shooting experience. Either can be a practical choice for trap, skeet, or sporting clays when matched with the right configuration.
Gauge, barrel length, choke selection, stock fit, and ammunition all influence performance. A well-fitted 870 may feel more natural than a poorly fitted semi-auto, while an 11-87 can be especially appealing during long practice sessions where repeated recoil becomes tiring.
Action Design And Shooting Rhythm
The Remington 870 uses a manual pump action. After firing, the shooter must move the fore-end rearward and forward to eject the spent shell and chamber the next round. This action is mechanically simple and gives the shooter direct control over cycling, regardless of moderate changes in shotshell load.
That manual operation requires practice. A smooth, consistent pump stroke helps prevent hesitation between targets, especially in doubles or sporting-clay presentations. For single-target disciplines such as many trap games, the 870’s action is easy to manage and can become second nature with regular drills.
The 11-87 cycles through gas operation. Propellant gases drive the action, ejecting the fired shell and loading the next one automatically. This can make follow-up shots feel quicker and reduces the physical movement required between targets, although the system depends more heavily on proper ammunition, cleaning, and component condition.
Recoil And Long Range Sessions
Recoil is one of the clearest differences between these Remington shotguns. The 11-87’s gas system absorbs and spreads some of the firing impulse, often producing a softer push than a comparable pump-action 870. Shooters who spend several hours at a sporting-clays course may appreciate that reduced fatigue.
The 870 can still be comfortable with suitable loads and a properly fitted stock. Light target ammunition, a quality recoil pad, and an appropriate stock length can make a meaningful difference. Because the pump does not rely on gas pressure to cycle, it is also less sensitive to light-load cycling issues.
Perceived recoil varies from person to person. A heavier shotgun can feel steadier, while a stock that is too long or has excessive drop can make even mild ammunition unpleasant. Trying both platforms, where lawful and practical, is useful before committing to a purchase.
Configuration For Trap, Skeet, And Sporting Clays
For trap, shooters often favor longer barrels and tighter choke options because targets generally travel away from the station. An 870 with a 28- or 30-inch barrel can provide a stable swing and a deliberate sighting plane. An 11-87 in a similar configuration offers the same general advantages while adding semi-automatic cycling.
Skeet typically rewards a quicker, more responsive setup. A shorter barrel and more open choke arrangement can help with crossing targets at close range. The 11-87 may suit shooters who want rapid second shots, while the 870 offers a controlled rhythm that many traditionalists enjoy.
Sporting clays vary from station to station, so versatility matters. Interchangeable choke tubes, a comfortable stock, and reliable cycling are often more important than choosing one action type solely by reputation. Before ordering, review the product description for gauge, barrel length, choke system, and included accessories. If you are organizing a full range day, this range bag guide can help with preparation.
| Feature | Remington 870 | Remington 11-87 |
|---|---|---|
| Action | Pump-action | Gas-operated semi-automatic |
| Follow-up shots | Requires manual cycling | Cycles automatically |
| Recoil character | Direct and comparatively sharper | Generally softer-feeling |
| Maintenance | Straightforward and relatively simple | More frequent gas-system cleaning |
| Ammunition flexibility | Broad tolerance when operated correctly | May prefer loads that reliably cycle |
| Clay-shooting appeal | Durable, controllable, uncomplicated | Fast follow-up shots and reduced fatigue |
| Best fit | Shooters who value simplicity and practice-driven rhythm | Shooters who prioritize speed and recoil management |
Reliability And Maintenance
The 870’s appeal includes its uncomplicated operating system. With routine cleaning, lubrication at appropriate contact points, and inspection of the action and magazine components, it can remain dependable through regular range use. The pump action also gives the shooter a clear mechanical way to chamber the next shell.
The 11-87 has additional parts associated with its gas system, including seals and related components that need inspection and cleaning. Fouling can affect cycling if maintenance is neglected. This is not a reason to avoid the model; it simply means the owner should follow the manufacturer’s maintenance guidance and pay attention to changes in ejection or loading behavior.
Both shotguns should be checked for safe function before a clay session. Confirm that the bore is clear, inspect the barrel and choke installation, and use only ammunition that matches the firearm’s gauge and chamber specifications. Safe handling rules remain essential whether the action is manually operated or self-loading.
Choosing Gauge And Ammunition
A 12-gauge 870 or 11-87 offers the broadest selection of clay loads and a substantial shot payload. It is a common choice for trap, skeet, and sporting clays, though some shooters find the additional weight and recoil less comfortable during extended sessions.
A 20-gauge model can be easier to carry and may feel livelier in the hands. It typically produces less shot payload, so careful choke and ammunition selection becomes more important as distance increases. For new or smaller-framed shooters, a 20-gauge can provide an approachable path into clay sports without sacrificing practical performance.
Use target loads intended for clay shooting and verify the required shot size, velocity, and shell length for the specific firearm. Ammunition should be stored and transported responsibly according to local law and range rules. When reviewing an online order, keep the retailer’s shipping restrictions and destination requirements in mind, particularly for ammunition and regulated products.
Practical Buying Considerations
The best choice depends on your priorities, the clay discipline you shoot most often, and the way the gun fits your body. A pump may be the better value for a shooter who wants rugged simplicity and does not mind practicing the action. A semi-auto can be the stronger match for someone who wants fast follow-up shots and lower perceived recoil.
Consider stock dimensions, overall weight, rib design, sight picture, choke compatibility, and the availability of replacement parts. A model that fits comfortably and points naturally is usually more useful than one chosen only for its action type. If purchasing online, use the retailer’s product details carefully and arrange shipment of the firearm to a compliant FFL dealer where required.
Before placing an order, these practical checks can narrow the decision:
- Choose the gauge and chamber length that match your intended clay loads.
- Select barrel length and choke options suited to trap, skeet, or sporting clays.
- Prioritize stock fit, recoil comfort, and natural point of aim.
- Confirm local laws, FFL requirements, and ammunition shipping rules.
- Review the estimated dispatch date before scheduling pickup or a range visit.
Once the preferred configuration is clear, verify the listing, shipping details, and dealer information before completing the purchase. You can review selected products and proceed through the Remington shopping cart when ready.
For a straightforward, durable clay gun, the 870 remains a compelling choice. For automatic cycling, quicker follow-up shots, and a softer recoil impulse, the 11-87 deserves close consideration. Choose the platform that fits your shooting style, maintain it consistently, and spend time practicing safe, repeatable gun handling at the range.